Tuesday, 12 June 2012

Same-Sex Marriage

A huge issue across the world right now is that of same-sex marriage. In countries all over the world there has been debate over whether we should allow people of the same-sex to get married. And the results at the moment are disturbing. Last month voters in North Carolina voted FOR a constitutional amendment defining marriage solely as a union between one man and one woman. This made NC the 30th state to openly ban same-sex marriage. Today in the UK the Church of England has spoken out against gay marriage which the government have been proposing should go ahead. Currently in the UK you can have a “civil partnership” which as I understand is a marriage in everything but name and legal status. 

Here’s a section from BBC News about what the Church of England has said:

The Church of England said by opening marriage to gay couples, an institution defined for centuries to be exclusively between a man and a woman would have its meaning "hollowed out" and reduced to the level of a "content free", "consumerist", agreement.

The irony here is ridiculous given the timing of this. On this very day in 1509 King Henry VIII married his first wife, Catherine of Aragon. As every good history student knows Henry decided he wanted a divorce but as the Catholic church wouldn’t allow it he set up the Church of England. So the CofE was set up specifically for the purpose of a divorce. So this organisation against redefining marriage was set up specifically to redefine marriage.

I am in no way an expert in the religious side of things but as far as I can tell the majority, if not all, of the “homosexuality is a sin” bit, is in the Old Testament. Now this comes largely down to religious beliefs but most people do not take most of the Old Testament literally. The modern viewpoint is generally that it is a series of stories which are a guidance on how to live your life. Much of it can be kind of considered irrelevant. But isn’t it odd how these bits are often taken unquestioningly. Let’s not forget this is a document which is extraordinarily old when people’s viewpoints where different. Jesus himself wandered around with 12 guys all the time. And can you imagine Jesus returning to Earth and telling gay people to stop being gay and he will forgive them. I know I’m not religious but if I was I would think Jesus would happily accept people being homosexual.

But fine (I say fine but I don’t mean fine), if religious groups are too stubborn and/or stupid to allow gay marriage then we can manage without them. When/if I eventually get married it’s extremely unlikely that it will be in a church. For one thing I was never christened so I’m not entirely sure it would be allowed anyway. But not being religious it would be a sham to get married in a religious ceremony. Straight people get married in registry offices and all sorts of weird places (caves, beaches etc) so there’s no reason gay marriage couldn’t happen alongside these things.

I do wonder quite why gay people have been picked upon so much. I think it’s the traditional human fear of the unknown. This is largely think is what causes racism but that’s a relatively minor issue these days compared to what it used to be. In the majority of the world people have equal rights no matter what their race. But yet gay people do not. I can sort of understand an initial fear of other races at the time when races just did not mix but homosexuality is not a new thing. All sorts of famous people were gay, or at least there is strong evidence to suggest they were. For example: Alexander the Great, Emperor Hadrian, Leonardo Da Vinci, Michelangelo, Tchaikovsky, Oscar Wilde, E.M Forster, Siegfried Sassoon, Rupert Brooke and countless overs. It can’t be denied that all of those people did incredible things regardless of their sexuality.  And that’s kind of the point of my argument. Being gay makes you no worse than any other person. Loving someone is always a good thing, it doesn’t matter whether they are the same sex or not. In a world where heterosexual marriages can last only a few days and divorce rates are higher than ever, how can it be argued that same-sex marriage ruins the sanctity of it?

It would be nice to think that within the next couple of years gay marriage would become a common sight across the world but it seems unlikely. I hope though that my generation can see past the issues our forebears have and will be one day able to make a world which is much closer to being truly equal. By all means insert your own opinion in the comments section and I will discuss them in a post at a later date.

I think I’ll end with a few funny but still with serious messages, placards that have been held up to support gay marriage and/or gay rights. We just can’t have a world without people like this!

4 comments:

  1. lewis Andrews - Oakes3 July 2012 16:15

    I agree that that institutions have the right to make these categories by which they recognise people i.e marriage. But just as they have the right to exclude certain people from being part of their group, everyone else has the right to think less of them for discriminating against these vulnerable minorities. My point is, why shouldn't the church ignore that old testament rubbish and welcome the gay community giving them equal marital rights? The church leaves out and ignores all the other shite about slavery and racism in exodus, so why not the discrimination against gay people like Leviticus 20:13. I know the church does a lot of good in the world but it's shortcomings need to be addressed and I think this is one of them. 

    ReplyDelete
  2. Firstly, God loves everyone unconditionally and he definitely doesn't love gay people any less than heterosexual people! I'm not 100% sure what I think about this debate and I definitely don't want to offend anyone. I think that civil partnerships should come with all the same legal rights etc. as marriage however I don't think the actual term 'marriage' should be used. This isn't because I think they shouldn't be able to be together, it's because the term 'marriage' means being joined together in the sight of God and in essentials the bible and the Christian faith don't agree with homosexuality. People tend to live together and sleep together before marriage now anyway and so I feel that the value of marriage is no longer in finally being able to live and sleep together after months or years of waiting during engagement but rather that the value of marriage lies in declaring before God your wish to be joined together in holy matrimony.

    ReplyDelete
  3. lewis Andrews - Oakes3 July 2012 16:16

    Why does God give a fuck about whether men marry other men? If morality doesn't exist to serve people's happiness and well-being then what's the point in it? If you use scripture (word of God) to try to prove that homosexuality is wrong, then first you have to prove that God exists and then you have to prove that the bible is the word of God. And even if you managed to do that you still haven't proved that homosexuality is wrong. You've just proved it's wrong in Gods opinion. And why should that be a basis for morality? It's just arbitrary rules made up by an entity that you can't prove exist. In short, Divine Command theory can go fuck itself alongside any other lame excuse that justifies discrimination against Gay people.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Amen. Says the not religious girl to the criticism of gay marriage by religions. I can't believe the Church of England has vocally opposed gay marriage! I find that absurd. But in some strange way I find it comforting that this isn't just an American phenomenon. The rest of the world is messed up, too!

    ReplyDelete

I love getting your comments! Share your thoughts or just say hi!

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...